Management system

Spreadsheet vs. management system - top 10 reasons why a tool is better than the traditional way

Discover the top 10 reasons why agile tools outperform traditional spreadsheets in managing security compliance, from centralized management to continuous improvement.

Article contents

ISO 27001 collection
Spreadsheet vs. management system - top 10 reasons why a tool is better than the traditional way
NIS2 collection
Spreadsheet vs. management system - top 10 reasons why a tool is better than the traditional way
Cyberday blog
Spreadsheet vs. management system - top 10 reasons why a tool is better than the traditional way

Staying compliant with standards and regulations such as ISO 27001, ISO 9001, ISO 14001, NIS2, GDPR, DORA or ISO 42001 is a major task for most companies. Many still use spreadsheets, Word documents, and shared folders to manage policies and track progress. This works at first, but quickly becomes messy and hard to maintain.

Management system software tools like Cyberday are built to replace that chaos. They centralize your documentation, automate tracking, and help you keep up with framework updates.

If you're building e.g. an information security management system (ISMS), a quality management system (QMS), an environmental management system (EMS), or an integrated management system that combines several frameworks, dedicated software reduces manual work and makes continuous compliance much easier. Here are 10 practical reasons why using a dedicated tool is a smarter way to run your management system.

1. Centralized management creates a single source of truth

One of the biggest limitations of spreadsheets is that information quickly becomes scattered across multiple files, folders and document versions.

Managing compliance in a centralized platform ensures that all your compliance data is organized in just one single place, providing easy and quick access for your team. This centralized approach reduces the risk of inconsistencies and simplifies the tracking of compliance activities, ensuring nothing falls through the cracks. Instead of spending time searching for information, teams can focus on improving compliance and reducing risk.

2. Easily map one requirement across multiple frameworks

Management system tool simplifies this process by automating the mapping of controls and policies to various compliance frameworks. With built-in functionalities, it can effortlessly link your organization’s security controls to multiple standards, ensuring comprehensive and accurate compliance. The tool's advanced features and database keep track of changes across frameworks, so you are always working with the most up-to-date information and you avoid wasting time and effort on similar requirements from different frameworks.

This  approach not only saves time but also reduces the risk of human errors, making your compliance efforts more accurate. This reduces duplicate work while making compliance more consistent and easier to maintain.

3. Audit readiness: Be prepared at all times

Preparing for an audit often becomes a project of its own when compliance is managed through spreadsheets and separate documents. Working management system tool ensures you are always prepared for a compliance audit by centralizing all compliance data, documentation, and evidence in a single, organized platform. This approach eliminates the chaos and inefficiencies associated with managing multiple spreadsheets and documents, which can lead to version control issues and data discrepancies.

In contrast, managing compliance work in spreadsheets or documents often leads to fragmented and decentralized data, making it difficult to maintain a consistent and up-to-date compliance posture. The manual nature of spreadsheets increases the likelihood of errors and omissions, which can be detrimental during an audit.

With real-time collaboration features, an agile tool allows multiple team members to work simultaneously on compliance tasks, ensuring that all updates and changes are instantly reflected across the platform. This real-time capability minimizes the risk of outdated or inconsistent information, which is crucial for maintaining audit readiness.

Integrated task management within a management system tool allows for clear assignment of responsibilities, tracking of progress, and setting of deadlines. This structured approach ensures that all compliance tasks are completed on time and that there is a clear audit trail, making it easier to demonstrate compliance during an audit.

Management system software keeps documentation, evidence, responsibilities and progress continuously up to date. Built-in reporting provides a real-time overview of compliance status, allowing organizations to identify gaps long before an auditor arrives.

4. Enable real-time collaboration across the organization

Compliance is rarely the responsibility of a single person. Asset owners, HR, IT, management and business units all contribute information that needs to remain accurate and current. When using a spreadsheet, collaboration can become challenging and chaotic. For instance, delegating asset inventory maintenance to asset owners is nearly impossible with Excel. Multiple users attempting to update the same file often leads to version control issues, conflicting changes, and data corruption. This fragmented approach not only hampers efficiency but also increases the risk of errors, which can be detrimental to maintaining compliance.

In contrast, management system software like Cyberday offer a seamless real-time collaboration experience. These kind of platforms allow multiple users to work simultaneously without the risk of conflicting changes. Responsibilities can be assigned directly to process owners, while integrations with tools like Microsoft Teams or Slack help notify users when action is required.This level of integration and real-time communication is something spreadsheets simply cannot offer, making agile tools a far superior choice for managing cyber security compliance.

You can see in the user column that there are different asset owners assigned. Every asset owner can keep track of their own assigned asset.

5. Keep up with changing requirements automatically

Compliance frameworks evolve continuously. Standards are updated, regulations change and new guidance is published regularly.When using spreadsheets, every update requires manual review and changes throughout multiple documents.

Management system software helps organizations stay informed about framework updates and highlights where additional attention may be required. Instead of constantly monitoring regulatory changes manually, teams can focus on implementing improvements that matter. Automation reduces the risk of overlooking important updates while saving significant administrative effort.

For example, read how ISO 27001 changed from 2013 version to 2022 version.

6. Scale your management system as your organization grows

When it comes to scaling compliance efforts, the limitations of spreadsheets become rather strongly clear. What works for ten employees often no longer works for one hundred. Spreadsheets can quickly become unwieldy as your organization expands, leading to fragmented data and challenging management. Everything, from tracking compliance requirements to assigning roles, becomes increasingly complex and error-prone.

On the other hand, management system software like Cyberday is designed to grow with your needs seamlessly. It effortlessly accommodates an increasing amount of data and users while maintaining optimal performance. This ensures that your compliance management remains efficient and streamlined, regardless of how large your organization becomes. You can simply assign ownership and responsibilities of different kinds of items to different users at any time. This flexibility also makes it suitable whether you're maintaining a single management system or an integrated management system covering multiple business areas.

7. Generate reports and insights instantly

When it comes to information security compliance, the ability to generate accurate and timely reports is crucial for making informed decisions and demonstrating compliance to stakeholders, auditors or the management. Spreadsheets, while being flexible, require manual data entry and manipulation to create reports. This process is not only time-consuming but also prone to human error, which can lead to inaccurate or incomplete reports. Additionally, the manual effort involved in updating and maintaining these reports can divert valuable time and resources away from other critical compliance activities.

In contrast, tool like Cyberday offers built-in reporting and analytics capabilities that provide insights at your fingertips. With just one click, these tools can generate comprehensive reports by automatically fetching the necessary information from (in Cyberday's case) task cards and other data sources within the platform. This automation ensures that the reports are always easy to get up-to-date and accurate, significantly reducing the risk of errors associated with manual data handling.

Moreover, agile tools offer advanced analytics features that can help identify areas for improvement in your cyber security compliance efforts. These insights can be invaluable for proactive risk management and continuous improvement of your ISMS. The ability to quickly generate detailed reports also facilitates easier communication with stakeholders, auditors, and regulatory bodies, ensuring that you can demonstrate compliance effectively and efficiently.

A report just one click away. This dream becomes reality when using agile tools like Cyberday. Simple create a report with any template from the library. Decide the contents, the language and adjust any detail to your liking.
Here you can find the report library of Cyberday with several ready-to-create via one click kind of reports. We have different kinds of reports available, depending on your needs. The reports we have are for example compliance reports, security statements, embeddable reports, legal descriptions, audit reports, policy documents, visual reports, management reports

8. Support continuous improvement instead of static documentation

Standards such as ISO 27001, ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 all emphasize continual improvement as part of an effective management system. But sppreadsheets generally become static documentation that is only updated before audits.

Management system software encourages continuous improvement through regular reviews, reminders, follow-up activities, metrics and improvement actions. Organizations can identify trends, monitor performance and improve processes throughout the year instead of only reacting during audit season.

9. Integrate tasks directly into everyday work

Management system software combines documentation with task management. Responsibilities, deadlines, approvals, evidence and progress are all connected to the relevant requirement, making accountability much clearer.

One of the most significant advantages of using an agile tool like Cyberday for security compliance is the integrated task management feature. Unlike spreadsheets or Word documents, which lack built-in task management capabilities, an agile tool provides a centralized platform where tasks can be assigned, tracked, and managed efficiently. This integration ensures that all team members are on the same page, reducing the risk of miscommunication and missed deadlines.

With the tool, you can easily assign tasks to specific team members, set deadlines, and monitor progress. This level of oversight is crucial and timely implementation of policies and controls can make the difference between compliance and non-compliance. The ability to track the status of each task ensures that nothing falls through the cracks, which is a common issue when using spreadsheets or documents.

The integrated task management feature also facilitates better accountability. Each task can be linked to specific compliance requirements, documentation items, guidelines and so on, making it clear who is responsible for what. This transparency is essential for audit readiness, as it provides a clear trail of actions taken to meet compliance standards. In a spreadsheet, this level of detail is hard to achieve without extensive manual effort.

Finally, the ability to streamline workflows through integrated task management contributes to continuous improvement. Agile tools provide features for regular reviews and updates, allowing you to optimize your management system continuously. This is a great contrast to the static nature of spreadsheets and documents, which require significant manual effort to update and review.

10. Reduce long-term compliance costs

When evaluating the costs and benefits of agile tools versus spreadsheets, it is essential to consider both direct and hidden expenses.

Spreadsheets appear inexpensive because almost every organization already has them. However, the hidden costs quickly accumulate through manual administration, duplicated documentation, version management, reporting, error correction and audit preparation.

Management system software automates repetitive work, improves collaboration and reduces manual maintenance. Features such as reusable templates, built-in guidance, framework mapping and automated reporting save significant time over the lifetime of the management system.

While dedicated software may require an upfront investment, most organizations recover that investment through improved efficiency, reduced audit preparation time and more sustainable compliance processes.

Start your 14-day free trial

Start your free trial today. No credit card required. Full access, zero risk. Cancel anytime.

Start free trial

Conclusion

Spreadsheets remain useful for simple tracking tasks, but they were never designed to manage modern compliance programs.

As organizations adopt multiple frameworks, involve more stakeholders and move toward continuous compliance, management system software provides a far more effective way to organize work. By centralizing documentation, automating repetitive activities and supporting collaboration, organizations can build an integrated management system that scales with their business and remains ready for audits throughout the year.